Husband Who Makes 300K Refuses To Spend $1300 on Wife’s 56th Birthday, Claims It’s Not Worth It

Author image for JR Atkinson
JR Atkinson • Writer and Editor
May 29, 2026 10:00 AM EDT

How much is too much to spend on a birthday?

When you get older, you should take every opportunity you get to celebrate with the people you love. Time is precious, and if you have reasons to celebrate, you should. You can't wait until the perfect time, because there is no perfect time. There is only the time you get. So if you want to go all out for your birthday, and it fits within your budget, then go for it. But what if you're in a partnership, and the other person isn't as all-in as you are? That's what happened here, when a husband was uncomfortable with his wife's birthday plans and wanted to stop her from doing them. He shared his story on the AITAH subreddit, and commenters took him to task for his response. As a rule, we should try not to dim each other's sparkle. Especially the people whom we love. We should be celebrating them and honoring their wishes and making them feel important, not making them feel like their needs are too much. Nobody wants to feel like they're too much. Everyone deserves to do what they'd like to do, especially for their birthday. And if it's not out of the budget, like it wasn't in this story, then those desires should be respected. If it's your 56th birthday and you want to go to a restaurant with a mariachi show, then you should get to do that. If your husband objects, then that's his problem.

Advertisement
  • 01
    Cheezburger Image 10634513664
    via Unsplash+ (Getty Images)

    An upset woman sits on the edge of the bed while her husband is in the background

  • 02

    Am I in the wrong for not wanting to pay for a 20-25 person birthday dinner for my wife's bday?

    My wife's birthday is coming up, and she wants to celebrate by inviting 20-25 people (mostly family) to a restaurant that has a mariachi show. It's not really a high-end place, but it has a minimum spend and the cost will probably be around 1250-1400 all told.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 03
    For context, we have a good income (300k/yr), but we also have significant expenses living in SoCal, including paying about $40k/year out of pocket for our kid's college. I tend to be more cautious about money, while my wife is more relaxed about spending—especially for social events like this.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 04
    Part of my hesitation is financial, but part of it is also the experience itself. The restaurant tends to involve waiting to get in, then sitting through the show, and then leaving. It's not really a setting where you get much time to talk or connect with people. So to me, it feels like a lot of money for something that's not that enjoyable or meaningful. And the food isn't really great. I think it's terrible actually.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 05
    I also had a reaction (which may be where I'm in the wrong) about the guest dynamic. In the past, when we've had larger group celebrations, many people didn't bring a gift or anything. Some are younger, some just don't seem to think about it. My wife says she doesn't care about gifts and just wants everyone there, but I think if you're hosting and paying for a big group, it feels a bit one-sided if there's no real acknowledgment.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 06
    She thinks I'm being cheap and that it's her birthday and she just wants to celebrate with a big group. I agree that her birthday should be about what she wants, but I feel uncomfortable footing the bill for that many people, especially for something I don't think is a great experience. And frankly, should we be paying for this sort of thing anyway?!? Seems like any time she takers friends out for their birthday, she also pays.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 07
    I'd be fine either doing something smaller where I pay, or having a bigger group where people pay for themselves. Or having something at our house. My wife on the other hand never seems to care about spending money. AITA for pushing back on this?
    via aja_ramirez
  • 08

    Commenters wondered why he was trying to control his wife's birthday wishes

    foxyfree Having those people around and celebrating by going to the show is what SHE wants to do for her birthday. It's your gift to her to be a good sport about it, even if the food is not that great.
    via foxyfree
  • 09
    Cheezburger Image 10634513920
    via Unsplash+ (Curated Lifestyle)

    Models representing a married couple have an argument on the edge of the bed

  • But it can be hard to compromise and to realize that you're not always going to get your way. Sometimes the people you love are going to make decisions that you don't respect, and you have to continue living with that. You don't get to control what someone else does, and you don't get the final word over their behavior. Especially on their birthday. They get to do what they want on their special day; that's kind of the rule. Keep reading for the full story and see what commenters had to say about it..  

  • 10
    herculepoirot4ever Bro, it is so much cheaper to pay for this party than it will be to pay for a divorce. And I know you're probably thinking that's overkill-but I'm 42, have similar or higher earnings, and have plenty of friends your wife's age in that same moment situation.
    via herculepoirot4ever
  • 11
    They are absolutely fed the f up with being invisible, with having to beg for the barest bit of attention, with settling for so much less than they deserve, with sacrificing for their spouses to climb the career ladder. I've had two friends in their 50's just this month throw up their hands and walk.
    via herculepoirot4ever
  • 12
    Like literally on Friday one of them lost her sh at their kid's graduation party because her husband started complaining about her buying nicer plates at Costco for the barbecue when the flimsy ones were cheaper. Just grabbed her keys and wallet and left.
    via herculepoirot4ever
  • 13
    If this is really the only time in your entire marriage (and courtship) that you've complained about spending money on her, sure, okay. Di on this hill. But if you're always complaining, nitpicking, finding reasons to dull her shine-take a step back and really think about what is more important to you.
    via herculepoirot4ever
  • 14
    And also just consider that you're slowly approaching the age where horrible sh just happens without warning. Cancer, heart attacks, strokes. There is zero chance I'm risking a what if over a mariachi band and $1500.
    via herculepoirot4ever
  • 15
    JJQuantum I was ready to be on your side because of the money but it just doesn't sound from the post like that's your main concern. It sounds more like you don't think the experience will be worth it overall - to you. That's why YTA, because it's not your birthday and it doesn't matter if it's worth it to you, only to her.
    via JJQuantum
  • 16
    Zeeman80 You make $300k a year and you're acting stressed over spending $1,300 on your wife's 56th birthday dinner with family? That's not financial responsibility, that's being cheap.
    via Zeeman80
  • 17
    She's not asking for a Rolex or a European vacation. She wants one night surrounded by people she loves, and instead of focusing on making her happy, you're sitting there calculating who did or didn't bring gifts last time like you're keeping emotional receipts.
    via Zeeman80
  • 18
    Marriage isn't a business transaction where every dinner needs ROI. If your biggest concern on your wife's birthday is whether the food is worth the money and whether relatives acknowledged you enough, then you're missing the entire point of why people celebrate in the first place.
    via Zeeman80
  • 19
    Careful_Society3757 YTA. "My wife's birthday is coming up, and she wants" followed by nothing but me, me, me, me, me. That poor woman.
    via Careful_Society3757
  • 20
    TheExistential_Bread Your post is a bunch of reasons why you don't want to go. But your wife does and it's her birthday. Also It's like 1/2 a weeks worth of wages for you guys. This isn't breaking the bank for you. Make your wife happy, book the restaurant and pretend to enjoy.
    via TheExistential_Bread
  • 21
    EDIT: for what it's worth, she's turning 56 EDIT 2: Well, I think this thread has run is course. According to Al, it's about 90-10 against me. The way I look at it, posting this was no lose situation. I am a big boy, I can take the criticism (even from the mean spirited ones). If I had more support, that would have been nice. If not, then I guess I would get some sense knocked into me. It looks like the latter.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 22
    For the record, we're both children of immigrants that were DIRT poor. My mom grew up sleeping on the floor and often didn't even have shoes. My wife and I are from the HOOD; more of my friends were k led by gang violence than graduated high school with me.
    via aja_ramirez
  • 23
    We'll be celebrating 26 years of marriage in August, assuming she doesn't fulfill the wishes of some people here and divorces me. Our two kids are thriving. So no, I am not an evil person. And yes, I expect to get k led for this update too. Anyway, I appreciate the input.
    via aja_ramirez

Want More? Follow Us and Add Us as a Preferred Source on Google.

Tags

long term relationship healthy marriage aita marriage relationship status birthday relationship-drama relationships story Reddit
Scroll Down For The Next Article